A Heartbreaking Tale of Neglect: The Legacy of Spud

Reading progress

On 13 September 2023, in a ruling that underscored the importance of our responsibilities to animals, the Muizenberg Magistrates Court found Ms Carol Ferreira (67) guilty of horrendous animal cruelty in terms of the Animals Protection Act 71 of 1962.

The Honourable Magistrate Vallie sentenced Ms. Ferreira to 12 months of imprisonment, suspended for 5 years. The sentiment behind Vallie’s words, “A dog cannot speak for itself and is dependent on people to take care of it,” resonated deeply and served as a poignant reminder to all.

Spud found in a collapsed state.

The Disturbing Discovery

In June 2022, after a complaint was lodged with the SPCA by a caring member of the public, Inspector Elani Graham found ‘Spud,’ a mixed breed dog, languishing in unimaginable neglect and suffering. The heart-rending sight of Spud, emaciated to the point of being unable to stand, painted a picture of prolonged suffering. The dog’s living environment was also found to be littered with faeces and refuse that seemed to have accumulated over days, and he was denied clean drinking water.

As further investigations were conducted, the severity of Spud’s condition became even more apparent. The veterinarians from the SPCA Animal Hospital, who examined him, reported distressing findings. From a severe wound on his chest, full of maggots and fly eggs, to numerous growths and sores spread across his frail body. Furthermore, an enlarged left carpal joint hinted at osteomyelitis, old fractures, or potential neoplasia, causing limited mobility.

The veterinary report painted a clear and disheartening picture: “This dog was the victim of chronic neglect. His overall condition, that of the wound and emaciated and collapsed demeanour show a prolonged period of inadequate nutrition, care and inadequate or complete absence of veterinary attention. It is my professional opinion that the animal I inspected suffered unnecessarily and for a prolonged period at the hands of those who were supposed to care for him.”

Our veterinarians, after assessing Spud, believed that the kindest and most compassionate thing to do was to humanely euthanise Spud. It’s a heart-wrenching decision, but our hope is that in doing so, Spud found the peace he may not have experienced in life.

The well-being of animals is always at the forefront of the SPCA’s mission. When an owner requests the humane euthanasia of their pet, the SPCA is bound by law to respect that decision and cannot overrule it. Non-compliance could lead to allegations of unethical conduct against our dedicated veterinarians with the South African Veterinary Council (SAVC).

A Plea to the Community

Animal cruelty, as this case brutally reminds us, is a serious offence. We implore community members to always be vigilant. If you suspect or come across any form of animal cruelty, please report it immediately to the Cape of Good Hope SPCA by calling our 24/7 Inspectorate Control room at 021 700 4158/9 or an email to inspectorate@spca-ct.co.za.

Let’s ensure no animal suffers as Spud did. Let’s be their voice.

Share This


Thank you for everything you do to help make this a better world for all animals.


Help Keep Our Inspectors On The Road
Your continued dedication, ongoing support, and passion for protecting the lives of animals is what make us successful. Thank you for everything you do to help make this a better world for animals.

Contact Our Inspectorate

The SPCA is the only organisation that offers a 24-hour Inspectorate service.

Contact our Inspectorate by calling us on
(021) 700-4158/9
083 326 1604 (after hours)

Or send an email to inspectorate@spca-ct.co.za

Inspectorate News

Shopping Basket